I get this question fairly often. The short answer is: Yeah, probably. But not as much as you might think.

The reason that water changes are necessary is that your pond is a mostly closed water system. Water leaves the pond mostly via evaporation rather than drainage, so it leaves behind almost all of the pollutants. Now, your filtration system takes care of a lot, if not most, of the pollutants. Larger things are caught by the mechanical filtration and removed, and chemical pollutants (like the ammonia from your fish waste) are partially treated by the biological filtration. The bacteria in your pond convert the ammonia to nitrates, which is then processed by plants and algae. However, depending on innumerable factors (like how big your pond is, how many fish you have, how many plants you have, what kind of filtration you have, how healthy your algae is, local climate, etc, etc, etc), this may very well not be enough for your pond. You’ll need to do partial water changes to remove some of these pollutants.

How Much Water Should I Change?

Opinion on this varies widely in the pond community, but one thing is pretty well agreed upon: in a healthy pond, a total water change should probably not be done. A complete water change is a huge shock to the pond, and everything in the pond (fish, plants, bacteria, soil, algae) will suffer for it. Partial water changes are key. But how much water should you change out? Well, some pond owners say that up to 40 or 50% changes can be done without too much harm to the pond’s ecosystem. I’m much more conservative, though. For my part, I’ve had plenty of hard lessons in how delicate a pond’s balances can be, so I recommend keeping it limited to 5 or 10% per week. Water testing can give you a much better idea of what your pond needs, though. Pollutants should show up in the water quality tests that you should be doing already, and you should experiment and find the least amount of water change that you can do while still having the desired effect on the water quality. If you find that your pond requires significant water changes to stay healthy, smaller water changes performed more often will almost certainly be less of a shock to your pond’s system.

How do I do the water change?

There are basically two parts to a partial water change.

1. Get the old water out

Getting the old water out is pretty simple, if not always easy. Some pond owners use a controlled overflow system that’s built into the pond, and this can be a really great way to get water out. It takes foresight when building the pond, though, and isn’t always practical.

You don’t need all of that, though. You can remove the water with a pump, a pump diverter on your existing pump, a shop vac or pond vacuum, or even just an old fashioned suck-on-a-hose-downhill syphon. I even get a good bit of the water that I change out of my pond out with a bucket, as I dip water out regularly to water other plants.

A quick note, again: evaporation doesn’t count as water changing, as it’s not the water itself that’s the problem, but the pollutants (which are left behind when water evaporates).

2. Add new water

A plastic trash can is a good place to let tap water age out chlorine.

This is the more complicated part. The biggest enemy for most pond owners in new water is Chlorine and its uglier cousin, Chloromine (of course, this may vary on how you get your water: well water often has more problems with sulfur). The easiest way to avoid tap water problems is to avoid it altogether and depend on rain. The problem with rainwater is that it isn’t as reliable in most places. This problem can be partly diffused by harvesting rainwater, giving you a steadier supply of it when you’re ready for water changes. Chances are, though, that you’ll have to rely on chlorinated water from time to time.  If you stick to small water changes, though, chlorine shouldn’t be too much of a problem. It evaporates from water rather quickly, so it should be pretty much entirely gone from your pond in a day or so.

For larger water treatments, or if your tap water is treated with Chloromine (which is much like Chlorine, but stays in water longer), you might need to do more testing. This may require either in-pond dechlorination treatment or pre-treating the water. I prefer pre-treatment, as I’m a big believer that, if I can avoid it, it’s better to not have a potentially harmful chemical in the pond in the first place.